Pablo Santos | Accounting and Trade Spend Manager, Cultivar
Accounting and trade spend for 75+ CPG brands
Last updated: November 6, 2026 · 6 min read
Key Takeaways
- Retailer deductions fall into six buckets, and the article’s mushroom jerky example sorts eight remittance lines worth $25,834 and finds $1,514 of invalid deductions.
- Each deduction goes through four checks in a set order, and the first confirms you have the distributor’s backup.
- KeHE suppliers file disputes in K-Solve within a 180-day window reported by SPS Commerce, and UNFI allows each dispute one appeal, so the strongest proof belongs in the first filing.
- Valid deductions belong in the gross-to-net lines between gross sales and net sales, which brings net sales and cash received to the same $275,680 in the example.
- Invalid deductions of $1,514 a month add up to $18,168 over a year, and the article recommends one hour every Monday for triaging each remittance.
Our example mushroom jerky brand invoiced $300,000 last month, and its UNFI and KeHE remittances paid $274,166. The $25,834 gap sits in eight deduction lines, each with a code and an amount. Retailer deductions are amounts a distributor such as UNFI or KeHE takes out of its payment to a CPG brand. They cover promotions, spoils, shortages, fines, and fees, and every one of them can be checked.
I’m Pablo Santos, Accounting and Trade Spend Manager at Cultivar, and I lead accounting and trade spend for more than 75 US CPG, wine, and spirits brands with over $100M in combined net revenue. The remittance is the distributor’s payment statement, and it lists retailer pass-throughs, such as slotting, right beside the distributor’s own charges, such as fines. We’ll take this brand’s remittance through five steps, which are sort, check, dispute, book, and track. The brand sells $3,600,000 a year, or $300,000 a month, at $42.00 per 12-bag case, and every figure here is illustrative.
What Are Retailer Deductions on a UNFI or KeHE Remittance?
Retailer deductions on a UNFI or KeHE remittance fall into six buckets, which are promotions, spoils, shortages, fines, slotting and free fill, and early-pay discounts. The 2021 deductions survey by the Credit Research Foundation (CRF) and Attain Consulting found that 5 to 10% of deductions were invalid. Most lines reflect agreed terms, so triage is about finding the exceptions.
Carixa, the deduction and order-to-cash software made by Smyyth, reported the Credit Research Foundation and Attain Consulting deductions survey in slides it prepared for CRF’s August 2023 Forum.
What Does Each Bucket of CPG Deductions Cover?
MCBs, or manufacturer chargebacks, are promotions whose cost the distributor charges back to you. The charge is based on the cases it shipped to retailers during the promotion period. Spoils are damaged, expired, or unsellable product, and retailer spoils are charged back based on the credits the distributor gave retailers. Distributors can also charge you for spoiled stock in their own warehouses. Shortages are receiving counts below the invoice. Fines cover late or missed delivery appointments, labeling problems, barcode problems, and low fill rates.
Slotting pays for a new item’s first shelf placement, and free fill stocks each new store with free product. Early-pay discounts are the ones a distributor takes for paying within your agreement’s window.
| Remittance line | Bucket | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| UNFI MCB, 2,160 cases × $4.80 | Promotions | $10,368 |
| KeHE MCB, 1,350 cases × $4.80 | Promotions | $6,480 |
| KeHE slotting for a new 40-store chain | Slotting and free fill | $4,000 |
| UNFI spoils | Spoils | $2,940 |
| UNFI shortage, 18 cases × $42.00 | Shortages | $756 |
| UNFI late-delivery fine | Fines | $350 |
| UNFI late-delivery fine, same delivery | Fines | $350 |
| UNFI “adjustment” | Held until backup arrives | $590 |
| Total, 8.61% of $300,000 in gross sales | $25,834 | |
I let the bucket tell me which document to pull first, and I hold the $590 adjustment outside the buckets until its backup arrives.
How Do I Tell If a Deduction Is Valid or Invalid?
Retailer deductions are valid when their backup matches a signed agreement, your distributor terms, your shipping records, or your delivery records. Any retailer deductions that duplicate another line or contradict those documents are invalid, and lines with missing backup stay under review until it arrives. Deduction backup is the distributor’s detail behind a charge, and I always ask for it first.
Put every line through four checks, in this order:
- Check that the backup is in hand, and log the line as under review until it arrives.
- Compare the line with lines you’ve already logged, because a duplicate goes on the dispute list.
- Match it against the signed agreement or your distributor terms, and dispute any difference.
- Test it against your own shipping and delivery records, and mark it invalid when they contradict it.
Promotional deductions that match the signed agreement are valid even when your trade plan says something else. The fix then belongs in the trade plan, and Pedro’s post on the signed contract and trade plan shows the two checkpoints that catch that gap early.
Our brand’s results come out like this. The UNFI MCB, spoils, slotting, and first fine are valid. On the KeHE MCB, 85 cases shipped after the agreed end date, so $408 (85 × $4.80) is invalid and $6,072 (1,265 × $4.80) is valid. The bill of lading and packing slip show all 18 shortage cases shipped, so the brand disputes the shortage.
| Result | Lines | Amount |
|---|---|---|
| Valid | UNFI MCB, KeHE MCB on 1,265 cases, spoils, slotting, first fine | $23,730 |
| Invalid deductions | KeHE MCB on 85 cases, shortage, duplicate fine | $1,514 |
| Under review | UNFI “adjustment” | $590 |
Caption: Save this beside your deductions log and put every remittance line through the same four questions.
How Do I Dispute an Invalid Deduction With UNFI or KeHE?
UNFI natural suppliers dispute most UNFI deductions in the Dispute Center inside myUNFI, with one appeal allowed on a denied or partly approved dispute. KeHE suppliers file disputes in K-Solve, the reconciliation tool inside the KeHE CONNECT Supplier portal.
I defined Cultivar’s trade spend workflows for KeHE and UNFI, plus Target, and I lead our deduction dispute process. Our brand files $1,106 with UNFI, the $756 shortage plus the $350 duplicate fine, and $408 with KeHE.
How Do I Dispute UNFI Deductions in the Dispute Center?
Log in to myUNFI and open the Dispute Center. Select the charge and enter the amount and reason, then attach your proof before you submit. UNFI’s Dispute Center help page names the statuses Draft, Submitted, Research In Progress, Pending Approval, Approved, Denied, and Appealed.
Request deduction backup by email at DeductionsBackup@unfi.com, because UNFI says backup is not available in the Dispute Center. UNFI allows each dispute to be appealed once, and its help pages describe an appeal as the place to add new or missing supporting documentation, so you gotta send your strongest proof with the first filing.
How Do I Dispute KeHE Deductions in K-Solve?
SPS Commerce reports that KeHE’s supplier policies, updated November 1, 2025, require you to dispute KeHE deductions in K-Solve within 180 days, so confirm that window behind your KeHE CONNECT Supplier login. For retailer-originated charges, your KeHE account team is a partner in getting the detail right, so loop them in early.
Where Do Valid Deductions Go on a CPG P&L?
Valid deductions go in the gross-to-net lines between gross sales and net sales, above gross profit. US GAAP treats cash or credit given to a customer, or to a retailer that buys through that customer, as a reduction of revenue.
The FASB and IASB staff paper of January 26, 2015 quotes the US GAAP rule, ASC 606-10-32-25, on consideration payable to a customer. Valid retailer pass-throughs such as slotting and spoils land in gross-to-net too, unless they pay for a distinct good or service.
Caption: Share this with your bookkeeper so every valid deduction lands in the gross-to-net lines.
I ask every client for one gross-to-net line per bucket, so the P&L shows which bucket moved. Cultivar rebuilt the Hudson Vineyards chart of accounts so each business line reports separately, with vineyard costs moved above the gross margin line to show true margins.
How Do I Track a Disputed Deduction Until It’s Resolved?
Track each disputed deduction in a deductions log that records its reference number, dates, status, and amount recovered. Update it whenever a remittance or a distributor decision arrives, because approved disputes return as credits on later payments.
Give your log these columns, and mirror UNFI’s status names in the status column:
- Record the deduction date, distributor, remit number, and deduction number.
- Add the reason code, amount, bucket, and matching agreement.
- Note the decision, dispute reference, date filed, and follow-up date.
- Track the status and amount recovered, and close the line when its credit appears on a remittance.
Our brand’s disputes resolve over the next few remittances. UNFI approves the dispute on the duplicate fine. It denies the shortage, then approves it after one appeal adds the carrier’s proof of delivery, which shows what arrived. KeHE approves the $408 dispute on its MCB. The backup for the $590 shows extra retailer spoils credits, so that line is valid.
| Final result | Amount |
|---|---|
| Valid retailer deductions, $23,730 + $590 | $24,320 |
| Valid deductions as a share of gross sales | 8.11% |
| Net sales, $300,000 − $24,320 | $275,680 |
| Cash received, $274,166 + $1,514 in credits | $275,680 |
Cash and net sales now agree to the dollar, and that tie-out is the moment I wait for every month. Founders who want a team to log and dispute deductions alongside them can lean on Cultivar’s trade spend management, which takes on the back-and-forth with distributors.
How Do I Stay Ahead of My Next Distributor Remittance?
Before your next UNFI or KeHE remittance arrives, set up a deductions log and name one person to triage every line the day the payment lands. Cultivar’s take is that the remittance puts trade spend, cash flow, and margin on one page, so the deductions log is where they get read together.
Give that person one hour every Monday, starting the Monday after your next UNFI or KeHE payment lands. Store proofs of delivery and signed promotion agreements in one shared folder they can open during that hour. Each month, share deduction totals with whoever plans your promotions, and fix the upstream step behind any cause that repeats, such as the example’s duplicate $350 fine.
If your last UNFI or KeHE remittance has deduction lines you can’t place, I’d love to help you sort them and dispute the invalid ones. Talk to me and the Cultivar team.
Frequently Asked Questions
What Is the Difference Between a Deduction and a Chargeback in CPG?
Chargebacks are one kind of deduction, and on a UNFI or KeHE remittance the word usually means manufacturer chargebacks, or MCBs, for promotions. Distributors also use chargeback codes for some spoils and compliance charges, and deductions as a whole cover spoils, shortages, fines, slotting, free fill, and early-pay discounts.
How Long Do I Have to Dispute a UNFI or KeHE Deduction?
KeHE’s window is 180 days under the November 2025 policy update that SPS Commerce reports, and the current policies behind your supplier login confirm it. For UNFI, email SupplierDeductionDisputeMgmt@unfi.com to confirm the current filing window for natural deductions, and file as soon as triage is done.
What Documents Prove a Shortage Deduction Is Invalid?
Your bill of lading and packing slip show what shipped, and the carrier’s proof of delivery shows what arrived. In our example, those shipping documents supported the dispute, and the appeal that added the carrier’s proof of delivery got the shortage approved.
Is It Worth Disputing a Small Retailer Deduction?
Small lines add up when they repeat. Our example’s $1,514 of invalid deductions would come to $18,168 over a year if the same amount appeared every month.
Related Resources
- Cultivar’s CPG accounting services cover tracking deductions, spoilage, and distributor fees with accurate monthly closes.
- Pedro’s post on accurate cash application of trade spend explains how applying each payment and its deductions correctly prevents false open receivables and inflated trade accruals.
- Alec’s Ice Cream weekly cash monitoring shows Cultivar watching cash weekly during the brand’s $11M equity raise, for Founders ready to watch cash as closely as deductions.
About the author
Pablo Santos
Accounting and Trade Spend Manager, Cultivar · Accounting and trade spend for 75+ CPG brands
Pablo Santos is the Accounting and Trade Spend Manager at Cultivar, where he leads accounting and trade spend for more than 75 US CPG, wine, and spirits brands with over $100M in combined net revenue. He owns Cultivar’s standardized month-end close, defined its trade spend workflows for KeHE, UNFI, and Target, leads its deduction dispute process, and built its loan support service, which has helped CPG brands secure more than $2M in working capital. Earlier, he spent 12 years at Cervecería Moonshine in Colombia, rising to head of finance and growing revenue to $6M at a record 24% EBITDA margin.